5 Top Youth Softball Leagues in New York City, NY

April 10, 2024

22 min read


B P202 5 Top Youth Softball Leagues in New York City Ny

Find the best youth softball ball league near you in New York City, NY

New York City, with its diverse population and vibrant sports culture, hosts a variety of youth softball leagues that cater to different age groups, skill levels, and competitive intensities.

From scenic parks in Manhattan to historic fields in Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, and Staten Island, the city's landscapes offer unique backdrops for the sport's ongoing legacy.

Join us as we round the bases to discover the best softball leagues in NYC, ensuring you find the perfect pitch to suit your love for the game.

Unlock your ballplayer’s full potential

Find the perfect vetted coach to build a solid foundation or take your player's skills to new heights.

Download the free app

1. Downtown Little League (DLL)

Details about Downtown Little League

  • Description: Founded in 1993, DLL is the largest single chapter Little League program in the U.S., with over 1,200 annual participants. It offers softballl for children aged 5-18 across lower Manhattan, including a Challengers Division for special needs participants. DLL emphasizes teamwork, sportsmanship, discipline, and respect.
  • Location: Throughout Lower Manhattan, New York City. 205 Warren St, New York, NY 10282
  • Website: Downtown Little League.

2. Greenwich Village Little League

Details about Greenich Village Little League

  • Description: GVLL, founded in 1984, serves over 800 boys and girls ages 4-16, offering baseball and softball in divisions such as T-ball, minors, and majors, with travel and tournament teams for 9-12 players. The league also provides summer, fall, and winter programs, including a Challenger Division for special needs children.
  • Location: Field Directry
  • WebsiteGreenwich Village Little League

3. Peter Stuyvesant Little League (PSLL)

Details about Peter Stuyvesant Little League

  • Description: Serving the community for over 61 years, PSLL provides baseball opportunities to more than 700 children on Manhattan’s East Side. It operates in the spring, winter, and summer, offering programs for children aged 4-16.
  • Location: East Side, Manhattan, specifically between East 10th and East 72nd Streets, east of Fifth Avenue. 722 E 16th Street,New York, New York 10009
  • Website: Peter Stuyvesant Little League

4. West Side Little League (WSLL)

Details about West Side Little League

  • Description: WSLL has offered baseball on the Upper West Side for many years, allowing young players to enjoy games in Riverside Park with views of the Hudson River. It features co-ed baseball for ages 5-18, girls softball for ages 7-18, and a special needs challenger division.
  • Location: Upper West Side, Manhattan, specifically between 59th and 120th Streets and between Central Park West and Riverside Drive.
  • Website: West Side Little League.

5. Our Lady of Sorrows Little League

These leagues represent just a portion of the opportunities available in New York City for young softball players.

They vary widely in terms of location, the age groups they serve, and the special programs they offer.

Each league has its own registration requirements, season schedules, and volunteer opportunities for families looking to get involved.

To help your softball player really excel in whichever league you choose, private 1:1 instruction is the fastest and most effective way to get her skill set up to snuff. 

How to Get Started with Private Softball Lessons

Embarking on the journey of private lessons can be a transformative experience for softball players looking to elevate their game. 

However, knowing where to begin can be overwhelming. 

Parents need a safe and straightforward process for finding, vetting, and connecting with professional instructors.

This is why coaching marketplace platforms like SeamsUp were made. 

It allows parents to apply filters to coaching profiles to quickly find the exact right exeperience level and price point to serve their daughter’s learning. 

And the app actually helps parents and ballplayers connect with elite coaches for both local in-person and remote style instruction. 

Also, SeamsUp does both a background offender database check and manual review of the coach and all claims the coach makes on their profile–so parents can rest easy knowing that their child’s instructor is both safe and exactly who they claim to be experience-wise. 

Regardless of how you go about sourcing your softball coach, following a structured approach, can help ensure a smooth transition into training and set the stage for a successful learning experience.

1. Research and Select Your Softball Coach

Firstly, research and select the right lessons coach. This is a critical step, as the right coach will not only improve your technical skills but also boost your confidence and motivation. 

Look for a coach with experience relevant to your specific needs and goals. 

Review their credentials, background, coaching philosophy, and review feedback from other students. All things that platforms like SeamsUp curate for you to chekcout in quick profile glance, so you can get on with your day. 

Many coaches offer a trial session or initial consultation, which can be a great opportunity to assess compatibility before committing to a full program.

Choose Your Softball Coach   Seams up Blog Graphic

2. Have the Right Gear for Your Softball Lesson

Next, ensure you have the necessary equipment and technology.

If going the local in-person lessons route, the equipment will depend on what type of private lesson you’re getting.

The usual lesson type options are: hitting, pitching, catching, fielding, sports performance training, and mental skills training.

Here’s the eqiupment you'd want for each.

Hitting Lessons

Hitting lessons will often require a bat and helmet. Instructors or the training facilities they conduct lessons inside of might be able to provide these items in a pinch. 

But much of the magic of private lessons is the work your child does at home in-between lessons, so it’s recommended to at least have a bat to practice with there. 

Depending on where the lesson is happening, if it’s on a field or inside of a facility, footwear is a consideration for this and all the future lesson types we’ll go over below.

Your daughter may also need cleats, turf shoes, or tennis shoes–depending on what surface the training is happening on.

Asking the expert you’ve chosen what she needs to bring for any lesson type you choose is always your best bet. 

Pitching Lessons

For pitching lessons, the only thing your daughter will usually need is her glove. 

If your pitching coach employs any helpful bands, cones, or gadgets, like spinners, into their lessons, they’ll usually provide all such training equipment for the lessons.

Catching Lessons

Catching lessons will almost always require that your daughter has her own full set of catching gear. This includes a softball catching glove (which is different from a baseball one), a chest protector, shin guards, and a catching face mask. 

Some coaches may be willing and able to work around a lack of catching gear in the first couple lessons, but she’ll need her own set to be able to get the most of private instruction.

If her league’s team has a set that they’ve been provided, usually your daughter’s team coach will be fine with you borrowing the set to use for her private instruction–because if she improves her game, the whole team improves as well. 

Fielding Lessons

For fielding lessons, the only thing your daughter will usually need is her glove. 

Again, any cones, flat gloves, or other speciality defensive tools will be provided by your private instructor. 

Sports Performance Training Lessons

For strength, speed, agility, and mobility sessions, AKA sports performance traning, the only thing your daughter will usually need is comfortable workout clothes. 

Though any good trainer will also recommend she bring a water bottle to each session as well.

Mental Skills Training Lessons

For mental performance traning, your daughter won’t really need any equipment–just a willingness to share her experiences on the diamond. 

However, it’s strongly recommended that she bring and employ a notebook to keep notes on the tactics she learns from the coach and on her own self-insights that may be revealed in the sessions. 

Remote Softball Lessons

Online softball lessons can come in all the various types we’ve already gone over: hitting, pitching, catching, fielding, sports performance training, and mental skills training. And the physical equipment needed by your ballplayer for each of the online lesson types is the same as their in-person lesson counterparts. 

But remote or virtual softball lessons also require: 

  • Reliable internet connection
  • A computer, phone, or tablet with a camera
  • Any software or apps, as advised by your coach. 

As a parent, helping your daughter create a designated practice area where they can train with their remote instructor without interruption will help mimic the structure of traditional lessons and keep her focused during sessions.

Remote Softball Lesson Gear   Seams up Blog Graphic

3. Have Clear Goals and Communication with Your instructor

The final key to successful private lessons is to set clear goals and communicate them with your coach. 

Whether you're looking to improve her batting average, increase power, or refine her windmill pitching mechanics, having specific, measurable objectives will help guide your daughter’s training sessions and provide a benchmark for assessing progress. 

Make certain your ballplayer is prepared to commit to regular practice and being open to feedback, as the consistency and willingness to adapt are key to improving their skills through online lessons. 

By taking these initial steps, you and your ballplayer are well on your way to a rewarding journey of development and improvement in the world of softball instruction.

See why SeamsUp's the #1 instructional app for ballplayers

Download the free app

About the Author

Mike Rogers

Co-Founder & CEO

Mike Rogers has spent a lifetime entrenched in baseball and softball as a player, a private instructor, a training facility owner, and the son of two college-level coaches.

Grow your business

Stay on top of the biggest trends in baseball & softball coaching. And get tips, tricks, and full step-by-step guides to accelerate your brand.